The Top 10 Medical Malpractice Insurance Providers in 2026

MEDPLI, a highly rated entity in the US insurance industry, specializes in providing Medical Malpractice Insurance. The firm stands out with an impressive 5-star rating from over 400 reviews, denoting a strong reputation for client satisfaction. MEDPLI offers a comprehensive range of services including Telemedicine Insurance, Tail Insurance, and Healthcare Staffing Insurance, among others. Notably, they cater to a broad spectrum of medical specialties, from Anesthesiology to Dermatology, ensuring customized coverage for each practitioner. Prospective clients can easily request a free quote online, showcasing the firm's dedication to user-friendly accessibility. A unique feature is MEDPLI's state buying guides, an invaluable tool that simplifies the complex process of buying insurance across different states.

Heffernan Insurance Brokers, an employee-owned company, has established a reputation for serving a diverse range of industries across the US, with a focus on niche business sectors such as healthcare. Offering a range of insurance solutions, they specialize in Medical Malpractice coverage, extending their services to home care agencies and allied health and specialty centers. Their commitment to their clients is evident, providing tailored solutions to protect valuable assets and aid in smart decision-making. The company's dedication extends beyond insurance, showcased in their active philanthropy through the Heffernan Foundation. With over three decades of experience and strong client retention, Heffernan Insurance Brokers has proven itself a reliable and versatile insurance broker.

Baxter & Associates is a seasoned player in the realm of medical malpractice insurance, serving a broad spectrum of medical professionals across the United States since 1996. As national experts, they offer a rich tapestry of coverage options, from malpractice insurance for healthcare professionals to errors and omissions insurance for insurance agents, and professional liability insurance for lawyers. Their strength lies in their ability to match clients with suitable carriers, backed by their extensive knowledge and wide network. Their offerings are tailored to the specific risks and needs of various practitioners, with a range of coverage limits and premium options. With a reputation for excellent service and an impressive track record, Baxter & Associates continues to be a trusted choice for many in the medical and business profession, year after year.

SVMIC sets itself apart as a premier provider of medical malpractice insurance, with a unique emphasis on being created by doctors, for doctors. Founded in 1975, this Southeast-based mutual company boasts a strong legal defense that has resulted in 30% fewer settlements than its competitors. SVMIC's resource library, rich with relevant content, provides invaluable tools for physicians and practice executives alike, and underscores their commitment to efficiency, effectiveness, and patient safety. Their strong focus on member benefits indicates a mutual success model that rewards policyholders. With a wide presence across various US states, SVMIC stands as a reliable and protective partner for any medical practitioner.

Contemporary Insurance Services, Inc. is a seasoned player in the field of medical malpractice insurance, providing tailored solutions to healthcare providers for over four decades. They adopt a unique bidding process, leveraging competition between insurance companies to secure the best rates for their clients. Their portfolio is expansive, serving a wide array of healthcare professionals from physicians to midwives. The company prides itself on its innovative approach and customer-centric ethos, as evidenced by their bespoke insurance offerings. In addition to their core operations, they also provide an insightful blog, addressing relevant industry topics such as cyber insurance and medical practice acquisitions.

eQuoteMD emerges as an industry leader in the US market, offering professional liability and medical malpractice insurance services to healthcare professionals spanning all 50 states. With a focus on affordability, the company ensures quality coverage without substantial costs, a testament to their dedication to serving the medical community. They leverage an extensive network of insurance companies, promising physicians and surgeons a wide array of options and competitive rates. eQuoteMD doesn't just offer coverage based on location and specialty, but also caters to various categories of medical facilities. With over 25 years of experience and a commitment to simplifying the insurance process, eQuoteMD is a trusted choice for medical professionals seeking comprehensive malpractice insurance.

Copic Insurance is a highly specialized insurer that focuses on providing medical professional liability insurance to healthcare providers in the United States. The company offers a comprehensive suite of services, including coverage for physicians, advanced practice providers, group practices, clinics, and hospitals, as well as cyber liability coverage. It further distinguishes itself by offering financial planning services, retirement plan consulting, and individual life and disability insurance. Importantly, Copic places a strong emphasis on patient safety and risk management, offering educational resources and support to healthcare professionals to prevent adverse outcomes. With a robust claims management system and a commitment to unwavering defense in the face of lawsuits, Copic Insurance appears to be a reliable and comprehensive choice for medical professionals seeking liability protection.

Diederich Healthcare, a division of Diederich Insurance Agency, LLC, offers quality and cost-effective medical professional liability insurance for healthcare practitioners and organizations. With over 50 years of experience, they strive to protect their clients against inherent risks associated with medical practices. The company has a well-structured process to help clients minimize malpractice insurance premiums and maximize cost-effective coverage. Diederich Healthcare prides itself on its commitment to integrity, compassion, and excellence, as well as a diverse selection of coverage options. Moreover, their extensive network of more than a hundred contracted insurance affiliates ensures greater market accessibility. Their dedication to personalized service, as testified by their clients, sets them apart in the medical malpractice insurance industry.

MagMutual is a U.S.-based mutual insurance company that stands out for its dedication to protecting and supporting healthcare providers with tailored medical malpractice insurance. With over four decades of experience, the company has insured over 40,000 physicians and healthcare organizations, demonstrating its solid reputation and commitment to risk reduction. The company offers a full suite of insurance solutions, including medical malpractice, cyber liability, regulatory, business, and workers' compensation coverage, ensuring comprehensive protection for the evolving needs of healthcare professionals. Additionally, MagMutual's Learning Center offers educational resources that have helped physicians reduce malpractice losses by 10%, underlining the company's commitment to empowering its policyholders with knowledge. Lastly, it is impressive that MagMutual has returned over $468 million in financial rewards to its policy owners, showcasing its dedication to sharing its success with those it serves.

Insureon emerges as a premier digital agency that specializes in small business insurance across various industries in the US. With an impressive suite of offerings from general liability to cyber insurance, Insureon sets itself apart with its instant online quotes, making it convenient for busy business owners to secure comprehensive coverage. They boast a highly competent team, including expert sales producers who guide clients through the complexities of insurance coverage. Their dedication to customer retention is evident in their account management team's commitment to service ease. What's more, their strategic partnerships with A+ rated carriers ensure customers receive competitive rates. Notably, Insureon's educational resources and customer acquisition strategies show a deep understanding of their clientele's diverse needs and search behavior.